RAINWATER HARVESTING
A rainwater collection and storage system is investigated, focusing on water quality at various points: from roof runoff to an underground concrete cistern. A prototype sand filtration system (designed to improve water quality) is built and then tested.
The result is complete removal of suspended solids.
The result is complete removal of suspended solids.
-----------------------------------------------
Introduction
Anita Van Asperdt and Eimar Boesjes treat rainwater as a valuable resource rather than a problem. The metal roofs of their newly constructed house are designed to collect and direct rainwater into an 8,000-gallon underground cistern where it is stored for later use. According to rooftop collection potentials, the typically wet winters of Oregon will provide them with enough water to irrigate their landscape and perhaps reduce their dependence upon municipal water utilities for indoor use.
Located in the south hills of Eugene, Oregon, the house is perched on a steep slope surrounded by Douglas fir woodlands. Rainwater from two of the four roof planes is harvested and stored in a concrete cistern while collection from the other roofs is diverted through a backyard streambed and ultimately into the abutting wetlands.
Fig. 1: Rainwater collection system
Fig. 2: Filter placement detail
The rainwater catchment system consists of painted steel roof structures (potable-safe coating). The water is artfully channeled from the rooftop to truncated downspouts that spill onto granite boulders at ground level. (see fig. 1) These boulders sit atop concrete footings that house pipes leading to the cistern inlets.
At present, the system is devoid of any filtration system to help purify stored water. The owners intend to add sand filters (fig. 2) and perhaps eventually supplement their system with additional means of filtration and/or sterilization in order to raise the water quality to potable standards.
After our initial tour of the home, we generated numerous questions for investigation. The discussions that ensued eventually led to the formulation of a hypothesis.
-------------------------------------------------------
Data & Analysis
Part 1 - Baseline Analysis of Rainwater Samples
Six common water quality tests were performed on five water samples to provide background on water quality issues relevant for rainwater harvesting. This process aided in formulation of a study experiment and provided context for the results.
pH
pH levels in the cistern water were predictably high due to leaching within the concrete structure. This is a standard chemical reaction with new concrete and will require a full flush to remedy the problem. Both the metal and shingle roof samples however were low, or acidic, in comparison to the EWEB norms. This is expected for rainwater.
Turbidity
The asphalt shingled roof was the most turbid, as was expected given its brownish color. This roof structure was not designed nor is it maintained for rainwater collection and was sampled to display the difference in water quality. Tap water collected at Moonshadow Drive tested higher than EWEB standards with regard to turbidity. This is reasonable since the water is bound to pick up some sediment during distribution.
Conductivity
Rainwater in its natural state, is very close to de-ionized but after passing over the zinc based anti-moss compound found on the shingled roof structure, conductivity is much higher.
Hardness
In its natural state rainwater is very soft and this tested true of the samples collected from the metal roof. There is little opportunity for the water to absorb minerals running off a smooth metal surface. After passing over the granite boulder and then into the cistern the water hardness levels begin to rise.
Total Suspended Solids
Given a chance to settle out, one would expect sub-surface cistern water to have fewer suspended solids than water sampled from the inlet. In this case however, bits of flocculant scum floating in the cistern water suggest bacterial activity, the presence of organic food matter, and thus suspended solids.
Coliform Colony Counts
Coliform counts presented here are not scientifically accurate since the collection containers were not sanitized prior to sampling. It is interesting to note however that residual chlorine in the tap water prevented any coliform growth in that sample.
------------------------------------------------------
Data & Analysis
Part 2 - Prototype filter sample analysis
These samples are not directly comparable to the ones tested in our baseline investigations. This is because we combined all rainwater samples and added organic matter (dirt, leaves, and twigs) to simulate a "first flush". However, it is interesting to note that our filter effluent was in the same range as EWEB's finished water, indicating the prototype was very effective in removing suspended solids.
In addition to (or perhaps as a result of) suspended particle removal, our prototype filter also removed all traces of color in the sample pictured above.
--------------------------------------------------------
Conclusion
Based upon our prototype testing results, we conclude that a sand filtration system will effectively eliminate all suspended solids and therefore improve the quality of stored rainwater at the Van Asperdt-Boesjes residence.
Because organic particles are removed from rainwater by the sand filter before entering the cistern, the potential for bacterial growth is drastically diminished. Such a filtration system could be easily implemented into the current design and will result in significant water quality improvements.
It should be mentioned however, that the elimination of suspended solids does not equate to water potability. To meet EPA standards for safe drinking, water samples should be tested by a certified laboratory. Many owners of rainwater harvesting systems use chlorine, ozone, or UV purification to ensure that their drinking water is free of pathogens.
This case study allowed us to learn about water supply on two very different scales. At the community scale, EWEB's Hayden Bridge facility embraces water in a technical manner with a huge supply flume that runs directly through the building's second floor landing. On a residential scale, the house at Moonshadow Drive celebrates water in an artistic manner with streams of rainwater falling over granite boulders. There is also an HVAC intake in the cistern that provides cooler air to the house, and an acoustic connection (through vents) to the water dripping into the cistern. By using water as an organizing principle, the owners of these two buildings of very different scale have found a way to address their environmental control needs and make the architecture special at the same time.
Rainwater Harvesting is a Vital Signs Case Study
prepared by Angela Matt and Joshua Cohen, Spring 2001.
prepared by Angela Matt and Joshua Cohen, Spring 2001.
Comment