• FluTrackers.com Inc. does not provide medical advice. Information on this web site is collected from various internet resources, and the FluTrackers board of directors makes no warranty to the safety, efficacy, correctness or completeness of the information posted on this site by any author or poster. The information collated here is for instructional and/or discussion purposes only and is NOT intended to diagnose or treat any disease, illness, or other medical condition. Every individual reader or poster should seek advice from their personal physician/healthcare practitioner before considering or using any interventions that are discussed on this website. By continuing to access this website you agree to consult your personal physican before using any interventions posted on this website, and you agree to hold harmless FluTrackers.com Inc., the board of directors, the members, and all authors and posters for any effects from use of any medication, supplement, vitamin or other substance, device, intervention, etc. mentioned in posts on this website, or other internet venues referenced in posts on this website.
  • We are not asking for any donations. Do not donate to any entity who says they are raising funds for us.

Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

Chuck

Moderator
http://www.sltrib.com/news/ci_12623865

Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths
H1N1 ? Weekly reports will help prevent public fatigue with the topic, officials say.

By Heather May

The Salt Lake Tribune
Updated: 06/18/2009 06:41:12 PM MDT

Health officials don't plan to release any more daily death tallies of Utah's H1N1 swine flu victims -- but that won't necessarily mean people aren't continuing to die after testing positive for the novel flu strain.

It's up to the state's 12 local health departments to decide how they report flu deaths. So far, the fatalities have been announced as they are confirmed, with a total of eight -- six in the past week -- since the outbreak started more than a month ago.

But that is changing to just once-a-week announcements: A compilation of deaths and hospitalizations will be put out by the Utah Department of Health on Wednesdays.

The change comes on the heels of a decision to no longer report whether flu victims had underlying health problems that put them at greater risk for serious complications.

An unusual number of deaths may spur an earlier release, officials said. But state health department spokesman Tom Hudachko said a routine daily death report "dilutes" the public health message.

"What we don't want is for the public to start to tune us out, because once that happens we'll have a significant challenge to overcome in the event that things get worse," he said in an e-mail.

The Salt Lake Valley Health Department, which has logged the state's most deaths and hospitalizations, agrees.

"That's probably what we'll be doing," said Gary Edwards, executive director of the county health department.

"It's better to have a message that focuses on what the public health concerns are, not just the fatality as it occurs," he said. "We're having a hard time getting the message out ... [that] when people are ill they need to stay home."

He said he does not believe that limiting reports will lull people into complacency about the flu since so many people in the community are getting sick.

Utah is thought to have one of the nation's most active outbreaks, with emergency rooms filled with patients reporting flu-like symptoms and one hospital reporting that it admits one flu patient to the intensive care unit a day.

The state and the county health departments pledged to inform the public in the event something extreme happens, such as dozens of deaths over a short period of time.

"If there were a whole bunch of deaths over a weekend, of course we would probably release that information," said Salt Lake Valley Health Department spokeswoman Pam Davenport.

hmay@sltrib.com
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

At first we had pretty complete reports regarding those who died.

Next we get reports that say the victim was between 20 and 30 but not much else.

Now we are told that we will not be told about the deaths at all.

While I predicted this in jest here on FTs on another thread I had no idea that any health department officials would actually take such an irresponsible stance.

What the **** is going on? The people of Utah need to do something about this. There is no excuse for this total lack of transparency. This policy is disgraceful and those who implemented it should be dismissed for violating the public trust and their duty as the servants of the public.

GW
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

I think it is very important to know what, if any, underlying or extenuating conditions there are to flu related deaths.
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

I think it is very important to know what, if any, underlying or extenuating conditions there are to flu related deaths.

Yes, but first you need to know that a death has occurred. This new policy essentially means they do not plan to report future deaths due to flu.

It strikes me the Utah DOH has taken a page from the Indonesian Minister of Health with regard to influenza case and death reporting.

GW
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

I think it is very important to know what, if any, underlying or extenuating conditions there are to flu related deaths.

Sure.

So now they don't have to ever let us know when someone who had been perfectly healthy has just died from swine flu.

And, for information we are now forced to rely on distraught families talking to media just like in Indonesia.
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

We keep tracking. We keep documenting publicly. We keep growing.

We keep targeting media personel - hoping one or two will actually take the time to read through some of these pages - and actually educate themselves - and then REPORT!

We keep issuing requests to Physicians & Nurses - saying leak the info. Give us the data!

We just keep doing.
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

Health officials don't plan to release any more daily death tallies of Utah's H1N1 swine flu victims -- but that won't necessarily mean people aren't continuing to die after testing positive for the novel flu strain. . . . But that is changing to just once-a-week announcements: A compilation of deaths and hospitalizations will be put out by the Utah Department of Health on Wednesdays.
I generally try to maintain an attitude of calmness, but this is one of the most outrageous statements that has emanated from public health officials here in the USA.

Many individuals and agencies have excoriated Indonesia for failing to report, as required by IHR, infections and deaths related to H5N1 (see this post for the current status on the lack of information from Indonesia).

Now we have public health officials in Utah following in the same dangerous footsteps of determining which information about H1N1 the public is entitled to know and when they are allowed to know it.

It is unconscionable that public health officials in Utah, and perhaps soon in other states, will start withholding critical H1N1 information about deaths, transmission mechanism, etc, from the local population. These agencies should provide accurate information so that people can draw their own conclusions. One has to wonder about the motivation of these and other government officials when they begin to take a paternalistic attitude about distributing this information to the very people that pay their salaries or choose them to protect the public health.
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

they still report weekly, at least.
As do these 122 cities in MMWR.

The few deths are not so interesting as the many ILI-cases
timely reported for Utah here:

daily_counts_fever.ratio_udh_16.png
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

Doesn't invoke a "warm and fuzzy" feeling.
Given our current technology, I assumed the public would have access to information as it develops. I assumed that much of that information would come from the agencies designed and funded to monitor emerging situations.
I didn't expect suppression of information in the US, especially this early in the situation. I hope they reconsider this decision.
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

gsgs,

Thank you for the graph. It is very interesting, but hard to read. I am assuming the x-axis is time over a few years, but do not wish to guess.

Can you post again with an x-axis?
 
Re: Utah health officials won't immediately report flu deaths

We keep tracking. We keep documenting publicly. We keep growing.

We keep targeting media personel - hoping one or two will actually take the time to read through some of these pages - and actually educate themselves - and then REPORT!

We keep issuing requests to Physicians & Nurses - saying leak the info. Give us the data!

We just keep doing.

flutrackers SHOULD have some sort of thread and/or 'sticky' for a place for physicians and nurses to leak out the info.....heck, they could go to their local library (or the one in the next town over) and anonymously post their findings.......if you where a physician or nurse who is seeing severe changes
in this.....wouldn't you want to get the information out so to save lives?????

I think they have a moral responsibility to the oath they took.....not to the laws that keep them quiet....

shame on them for not SHOUTING out what is really going on......if they keep quiet through this pandemic......history will hold them responsible along with TPTB for letting people die.
I am outraged that there is NO WARNING out there.....childrens lives are at stake, as well as our own.........

jmho
 
Back
Top Bottom