tetano
Editor, Senior Moderator
J Med Ethics
. 2020 Jun 3;medethics-2020-106467.
doi: 10.1136/medethics-2020-106467. Online ahead of print.
The Right to Know: Ethical Implications of Antibody Testing for Healthcare Workers and Overlooked Societal Implications
Kunal Vakharia[SUP] 1 [/SUP]
Affiliations
Abstract
After the initial surge in cases of coronavirus (COVID-19), the outbreak has been managed differently in different countries. In the USA, it has been managed in many different ways between states, cities and even counties. This disparity is slowly becoming more and more pronounced with the advent of antibody testing. Although many argue over the potential merits of antibody testing as an immunity passport to allow the economy to restart, there are other implications that stand at the heart of the bioethical debate that are often overlooked. Particularly with COVID-19, there are many uncertainties and the discourse alone of antibodies presumes misinformation that may outweigh the epidemiological benefits of antibody testing. Although this paper does not seek to eliminate antibody testing, it does highlight the need for appropriate counselling both on a personal level with each patient but on a more global level. This moral standard of appropriate education is key to allowing the continued autonomy needed during this pandemic.
Keywords: distributive justice; ethics.
. 2020 Jun 3;medethics-2020-106467.
doi: 10.1136/medethics-2020-106467. Online ahead of print.
The Right to Know: Ethical Implications of Antibody Testing for Healthcare Workers and Overlooked Societal Implications
Kunal Vakharia[SUP] 1 [/SUP]
Affiliations
- PMID: 32493712
- DOI: 10.1136/medethics-2020-106467
Abstract
After the initial surge in cases of coronavirus (COVID-19), the outbreak has been managed differently in different countries. In the USA, it has been managed in many different ways between states, cities and even counties. This disparity is slowly becoming more and more pronounced with the advent of antibody testing. Although many argue over the potential merits of antibody testing as an immunity passport to allow the economy to restart, there are other implications that stand at the heart of the bioethical debate that are often overlooked. Particularly with COVID-19, there are many uncertainties and the discourse alone of antibodies presumes misinformation that may outweigh the epidemiological benefits of antibody testing. Although this paper does not seek to eliminate antibody testing, it does highlight the need for appropriate counselling both on a personal level with each patient but on a more global level. This moral standard of appropriate education is key to allowing the continued autonomy needed during this pandemic.
Keywords: distributive justice; ethics.