Re: Deadly flu virus mutating rapidly: WHO
Thank you for the link (and for your productivity and leadership in the field). I see that they gave you some decent presentation times and included you on a panel. There must have been some organizers interested in science.
How was your work received in general? Did it stimulate some good discussion? Was it worth your time to attend overall?
I did have a good discussion with Ian Brown and a few other sequencers affiliated with the H5 Regional sites, and I did get a chance to meet NAMRU-3 people in person (Ken Earhart, Marshall Monteville, Jeff Tjaden, Magdi Saad, among others), but science at the meeting was in very short supply.
One of the more entertaining moments came when an audience member noted that calling various constellations of genes "genotypes", as in the "Z genotype", was incorrect, since gentoype refer to changes in gene sequences, and reassortment merely shuffles whole genes.
The heavy dependence on reassortment and "random mutations" was quite remarkable, even when phylogenetic trees of a single gene were being compared.
The influenza field has really created a fantasy world, which supports the scientifically unsupportable, by members supporting each other.