Vaccine hesitancy spills over to pet owners
Meghan HolohanToday at 3:39 p.m.
Rabies
Public Health
Over the past several years, Gabriella Motta, VMD, an associate veterinarian at Glenolden Animal Hospital in Pennsylvania, has noticed more pet owners arriving at appointments with questions about vaccines.
Some will accept only the minimum number of shots for their pets. Others believe that if their pets stay inside they do not need to be immunized, and some worry that vaccine components will cause serious reactions.
“Their concerns are coming from a good place—people love their pets and want to make sure they’re providing them with the best care,” Motta told CIDRAP News. “I explain to owners how serious side effects from vaccines are very rare and that vaccines prevent illnesses in our cats and dogs that are often fatal and can result in very serious traumatic and costly hospitalization.”
Motta conducted a survey published in 2023 in Vaccine with her brother, Matt Motta, PhD, associate professor at Boston University's School of Public Health, examining vaccine hesitancy in dog owners. About 40% of dog owners doubted the safety of canine vaccines, and over 20% believed they don’t work. Nearly a third of participants (30%) thought canine vaccines aren’t needed.
“We knew that some pet owners were reluctant to vaccinate their pets,” said Matt Motta. “Anecdotally, we know examples of people who don’t vaccinate their pets for any number of different reasons. And so what we wanted to do was to systematically set out to study it.”
Influence of COVID-19 pandemic
For the paper, the Mottas and their colleague Dominik Stecula, PhD, surveyed 2,220 dog owners about their feelings on pet vaccines in 2023. They wondered if the anecdotal examples they heard translated into a trend.“We wanted to understand whether or not this thing we thought might exist, canine vaccine hesitancy, actually existed and where it came from,” Matt Motta said. “What we found in this research was that people who expressed higher levels of canine vaccine hesitancy were more likely to report they hadn’t vaccinated their pets, or they were more likely to consider not vaccinating their pets.”
The researchers discovered that the COVID-19 pandemic influenced how people think about vaccines for their pups.
“The way you feel about COVID-19 vaccination is strongly associated with how you feel about vaccinating your pets,” Matt Motta explained. “If you’re the type of person who thinks a COVID-19 vaccine is unsafe, you are more likely to think that vaccinating your pet is not a good thing to do.”
Experts call this phenomenon “spillover,” in which beliefs about human immunization influence how people treat their four-legged friends.
“So much is tied into the COVID-19 pandemic and the COVID-19 vaccine rollout,” he said. “You just can’t disentangle those two stories.”
The pet wellness movement—which mirrors the human wellness movement and emphasizes longevity, using supplements, and eating raw-food diets, for example—also contributes to an increase in pet vaccine hesitancy.
“There’s such a very tight relationship between the pet wellness movement, the Make American Healthy Again movement, and vaccine hesitancy,” Matt Motta said.
The pet wellness influencers’ script seems eerily similar to that of human wellness influencers.
“They’re not saying, ‘Don’t vaccinate your pets,’” he said. “They’re just saying, ‘Doesn’t it feel like your pets get a lot of vaccines?’ Do you really need that booster shot every three years for rabies? Or could you just, through a titer test, demonstrate your dog has rabies antibodies?”
While the Mottas’ research focused on dog owners’ vaccine hesitancy, another 2023 paper in Vaccine found that many cats do not receive their core or non-core vaccines. Again, the researcher noted that how people feel about human vaccines influences their feelings on feline vaccines.
Serious reactions ‘very, very rare’
As a practicing veterinarian, Jennifer Quammen, DVM, of Community Pet Healthcare in Zionsville, Indiana, also conducts frequent conversations with pet owners about the pros and cons of vaccination.“I would say there are always concerns that folks have. They can be a lot of things: safety, cost, when the vaccine is needed,” said Quammen, president of the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA). “I would not say on the whole that I’m seeing increased numbers of questions about hesitancy.”
When it comes to safety, pet owners worry about their furry friends having severe reactions to vaccines. But the experts stress this is uncommon. “Adverse reactions are very, very rare,” Quammen said.
The way you feel about COVID-19 vaccination is strongly associated with how you feel about vaccinating your pets.
Matt Motta, PhD
Some people wonder if their pets might develop autism after vaccination. “We asked people about the possibility that these vaccines could cause autism, and a decent number of people were worried that it might,” Matt Motta said. “It was really striking that so many people would endorse these views.”
There’s no credible link between vaccines and autism in people, and experts do not think that dogs and cats can have autism. “Autism is not documented in veterinary patients,” Gabriella Motta said. “This scenario really underscores how vaccine hesitancy can often be rooted in false, unscientific claims.”
Common side effects that occur after vaccination in pets match those of people and can include achiness, soreness at the injection site, and lethargy. Some pets have an allergic reaction—either localized to the skin or systemic—but it’s uncommon. If a pet does have a reaction to a vaccine, their owners should talk to their vets about options to protect their pets.
“That’s a conversation we would have based on the individual animal,” Quammen said. “We do know how to manage these patients.”
Role of core, lifestyle vaccines
Veterinarians categorize pet vaccines into two buckets—core and lifestyle. Core vaccines for dogs are rabies and a combination shot that protects against distemper, hepatitis (adenovirus), leptospirosis, parainfluenza, and parvovirus (DHLPP). Lifestyle vaccines protect against Bordetella pertussis (“kennel cough”), which dogs in daycare or grooming often need, and Lyme disease.Core cat vaccines include a combination vaccine against feline viral rhinotracheitis, calicivirus, and panleukopenia (FVRCP), as well as the rabies vaccine. Outdoor cats might also receive a vaccine against feline leukemia virus (FeLV), which is considered a lifestyle dose.
“The non-core [vaccines] are again more [based on] risk assessment, and maybe not every animal is going to receive a recommendation for that,” Quammen explained. “That is truly based again on the lifestyle of the individual animal and the region they live in.”
Every state requires dogs to be vaccinated against rabies, while requirements for cats vary from state to state. Yet even indoor cats can be at risk for contracting the deadly virus if they escape outside or something like a bat enters the home and bites them. This is why veterinarians highly recommended them.
“If an unvaccinated pet displays rabies symptoms, the test for rabies involves euthanasia and submission of brain tissue,” Gabriella Motta said.
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) warned earlier this summer of an increase in people coming into contact with potentially rabid animals. The CDC doesn’t track pet exposures to rabies and has not received reports that the human rabies encounters are related to dogs or cats, Ryan Wallace, DVM, MPH, of the CDC’s Poxvirus and Rabies Branch, said.
But isolated cases of rabid dogs and cats have made the news. In August in Houston, a Siberian husky began displaying behavioral changes and neurologic symptoms associated with rabies. The owners explained to local health officials that the pup had killed a skunk earlier in the summer, but they thought little of it. After the canine’s symptoms started, vets euthanized the pet, and the health department offered its owners rabies vaccines.
Earlier in November, Bulloch and Evans counties in Georgia issued a warning after four dogs and cats in the area tested positive for rabies. At least one of the animals was a kitten, which means it could have been too young to qualify for vaccination.
Unreliability of titer checks
On holistic vet social media pages, people share ways to avoid vaccinating their pets. Many instead ask for their pet’s titers (antibody levels) to be checked. But experts caution that this is an unreliable and expensive way to determine if their pets are protected.“What that’s really doing is measuring antibodies in the blood, and, for some diseases, that can help us assess whether this individual animal likely has protection against that individual disease,” Quammen said. “Titers are not a replacement for vaccination.”
A problem with a titer check is that it’s unclear when the protection wanes. One day, a pet might have antibodies against the disease, but the next day, they’re gone.
“There’s no definitive way to say, ‘I’m going to titer test today.’ So then do I wait a year, six months, two years?” Quammen said.
If an unvaccinated pet displays rabies symptoms, the test for rabies involves euthanasia and submission of brain tissue.
Gabriella Motta, VMD
If rabies vaccination is required by a vet’s office, a groomer, or a boarder, most won’t accept a titer test as proof of vaccination. What’s more, most states won’t consider it proof that a pet is immunized.
“If a pet with an expired rabies vaccine and titer [test] were to bite someone, they would be treated as an unvaccinated animal,” Gabriella Motta said. “I will stress this to clients who ask for rabies titers, because I don’t think that is very widely known.”
A dog’s perspective
After retiring from the Office of Communications at the CDC, Susan Laird, DNP, RN, wanted to encourage vaccination and explain it easily to children. She started writing Healthy with Harvey, public-health blog posts told from the point of view of her goldendoodle, Harvey.“He’s big. He’s funny looking. We don’t clip his hair,” she said. “He loves children, and children really like him.”
Harvey often talks about vaccination, decision-making, and other public health topics such as wearing a helmet or handwashing. When the vaccine-advocacy organization Voices for Vaccines approached Laird about Harvey writing about pet vaccines, she embraced the challenge. In the post for the organization, Harvey talked about how his friend didn’t receive his parainfluenza vaccine and almost died.
“It was encouraging people to vaccinate, because you could get a vaccine, and you could prevent the illness,” she said. “My goal is not to scare the living hell out of people. Rather, it is to make them think and make better choices.”
Laird thinks that Harvey is the perfect messenger when it comes to pet (and human) vaccine hesitancy.
“People like the dog,” she said. “Where I may be offensive in my opinions, the dog is not. Nobody needs to argue with the dog.”