• FluTrackers.com Inc. does not provide medical advice. Information on this web site is collected from various internet resources, and the FluTrackers board of directors makes no warranty to the safety, efficacy, correctness or completeness of the information posted on this site by any author or poster. The information collated here is for instructional and/or discussion purposes only and is NOT intended to diagnose or treat any disease, illness, or other medical condition. Every individual reader or poster should seek advice from their personal physician/healthcare practitioner before considering or using any interventions that are discussed on this website. By continuing to access this website you agree to consult your personal physican before using any interventions posted on this website, and you agree to hold harmless FluTrackers.com Inc., the board of directors, the members, and all authors and posters for any effects from use of any medication, supplement, vitamin or other substance, device, intervention, etc. mentioned in posts on this website, or other internet venues referenced in posts on this website.
  • We are not asking for any donations. Do not donate to any entity who says they are raising funds for us.

CDC Chief: Oops...do over..enhanced airport screening announced October 8 - Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More American

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Criminal procedures will just end up costing taxpayers even more money and frankly, would be creepy posthumously. I'm sure that idea will get dropped after due consideration.

Fines and lawsuits are another matter.
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

.....Fines and lawsuits are another matter.

aka restitution for preventable costs.

.
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

I think this is probably a publicity stunt on the part of that Dallas DA. Is he perhaps up for re-election?
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

It is precisely this kind of stunt that makes me lose faith in the CDC. Temperature monitoring is likely going to result in a lot of people with mild colds and the flu being detained. Clearly those with Ebola, like Duncan can slip thru the cracks.
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Here's a better article:

Travelers from West Africa will Face Stronger Screening at US Airports

I think this is just window dressing and will do more harm than good, as AnnaLisa pointed out.
It's already been shown to be ineffective, as per Mr. Duncan's case. With up to a 21 day incubation, almost all screening procedures will be quite ineffective.
I actually find this move quite patronizing, as anyone with even a little knowledge of the illness knows this will not work. Which leads me to ask the uncomfortable question: How stupid do they think we are?
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Sen. Bill Nelson pushing for more security over Ebola concerns
Florida Sen. Bill Nelson is pushing for more security as concerns continue to rise over Ebola.

snip

In a letter to U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, the senator said he would like to see a ban of travel to the United States under existing visas for, what he calls ?unnecessary travel.?

He also suggested blocking the issuance of new visas for citizens of countries the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identifies as areas with high rates of infections.


more...

http://www.mynews13.com/content/new.../articles/cfn/2014/10/8/sen_nelson_ebola.html
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Sen. Bill Nelson pushing for more security over Ebola concerns
Florida Sen. Bill Nelson is pushing for more security as concerns continue to rise over Ebola.

snip

In a letter to U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry, the senator said he would like to see a ban of travel to the United States under existing visas for, what he calls “unnecessary travel.”

He also suggested blocking the issuance of new visas for citizens of countries the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identifies as areas with high rates of infections.


more...

http://www.mynews13.com/content/new.../articles/cfn/2014/10/8/sen_nelson_ebola.html

There is an interesting unscientific poll on that site. Apparently, 81% of respondents want a complete (69%) or partial (19%) travel ban (although the poll calls it a ban on flights). That's fairly intense pressure for any politician.
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

I live in the Orlando area and much of this economy is tied to tourism. I am sure Nelson's position on this issue is pressure from the industry.
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

This is the statement of the Governor of Louisiana:

Oct 03, 2014

Gov. Jindal: Stop Flights From Ebola-Stricken Countries

BATON ROUGE ? Governor Bobby Jindal called on the Obama Administration to shut down flights coming into the United States from Ebola-stricken countries.

Governor Jindal said, ?We should stop accepting flights from countries that are Ebola stricken. Even countries in Africa have cut back on or stopped accepting flights from countries with Ebola outbreaks.

"President Obama said it was ?unlikely? that Ebola would reach the U.S. Well, it has, and we need to protect our people. But the Obama Administration keeps saying they won?t shut down flights. They instead say we should listen to 'the experts.' In fact, they said it would be counterproductive to stop these flights. That statement defies logic. How exactly would stopping the entry of people potentially carrying the Ebola virus be counterproductive? This seems to be an obvious step to protect public health in the United States."

###


http://gov.louisiana.gov/index.cfm?md=newsroom&tmp=detail&articleID=4687
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

I live in the Orlando area and much of this economy is tied to tourism. I am sure Nelson's position on this issue is pressure from the industry.

I think you're right. I subscribe to a lot of travel industry twitter and email, and in the last couple of days have seen quite a number of discounts for airfare. It doesn't take much to cause people to cut back on something as discretionary as vacation travel.
 
Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Re: CDC Chief: Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

From: "Media@cdc.gov (CDC)" <sohco@CDC.GOV>
To: MMWR-MEDIA@LISTSERV.CDC.GOV
Subject: Press Release: ENHANCED EBOLA SCREENING TO START AT FIVE U.S. AIRPORTS AND NEW TRACKING PROGRAM FOR ALL PEOPLE ENTERING U.S. FROM EBOLA-AFFECTED COUNTRIES
Date: Oct 8, 2014 1:39 PM



CDC Media Relations
406-639-3286

DHS Office of Public Affairs
202-282-8010



Press Release


ENHANCED EBOLA SCREENING TO START AT FIVE U.S. AIRPORTS AND NEW TRACKING PROGRAM FOR ALL PEOPLE ENTERING U.S. FROM EBOLA-AFFECTED COUNTRIES

New layers of screening at airports that receive more than 94% of West African Travelers

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Department of Homeland Security?s Customs & Border Protection (CBP) this week will begin new layers of entry screening at five U.S. airports that receive over 94 percent of travelers from the Ebola-affected nations of Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone.

New York?s JFK International Airport will begin the new screening on Saturday. In the 12 months ending July 2014, JFK received nearly half of travelers from the three West African nations. The enhanced entry screening at Washington-Dulles, Newark, Chicago-O?Hare, and Atlanta international airports will be implemented next week.

?We work to continuously increase the safety of Americans,? said CDC Director Tom Frieden, M.D., M.P.H. ?We believe these new measures will further protect the health of Americans, understanding that nothing we can do will get us to absolute zero risk until we end the Ebola epidemic in West Africa.?

?CBP personnel will continue to observe all travelers entering the United States for general overt signs of illnesses at all U.S. ports of entry and these expanded screening measures will provide an additional layer of protection to help ensure the risk of Ebola in the United States is minimized,? said Deputy Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas. ?CBP, working closely with CDC, will continue to assess the risk of the spread of Ebola into the United States, and take additional measures, as necessary, to protect the American people.?

CDC is sending additional staff to each of the five airports and the new measures begin with CBP officers reviewing travelers? passports. After passport review:
? Travelers from Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone will be escorted by CBP to an area of the airport set aside for screening.
? Trained CBP staff will observe them for signs of illness, ask them a series of health and exposure questions and provide health information for Ebola and reminders to monitor themselves for symptoms. Trained medical staff will take their temperature with a non-contact thermometer.
? If the travelers have fever, symptoms or the health questionnaire reveals possible Ebola exposure, they will be evaluated by a CDC quarantine station public health officer. The public health officer will again take a temperature reading and make a public health assessment. Travelers, who after this assessment, are determined to require further evaluation or monitoring will be referred to the appropriate public health authority.
? Travelers from these countries who have neither symptoms/fever nor a known history of exposure will receive health information for self-monitoring, be asked to complete a daily temperature log, and be asked to provide their contact information.

Entry screening is part of a layered process that includes exit screening and standard public health practices such as patient isolation and contact tracing in countries with Ebola outbreaks. Successful containment of the recent Ebola outbreaks in Nigeria and DRC demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach.

In addition, exit screening measures have been implemented in the affected West African countries, and CDC experts have worked closely with local authorities to implement these measures. Since the beginning of August, CDC has been working with airlines, airports, ministries of health, and other partners to provide technical assistance for the development of exit screening and travel restrictions in countries with Ebola. This includes:
? Assessing the capacity to conduct exit screening at international airports;
? Assisting countries with procuring supplies needed to conduct exit screening;
? Supporting with development of exit screening protocols;
? Developing tools such as posters, screening forms, and job-aids; and
? Training staff on exit screening protocols and appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE)

Today, all outbound passengers are screened for Ebola symptoms in the affected countries. Such primary exit screening involves travelers responding to a travel health questionnaire, being visually assessed for potential illness, and having their body temperature measured. In the last two months since exit screening began in the three countries, of 36,000 people screened, 77 people were denied boarding a flight because of the health screening process. None of the 77 passengers were infected with Ebola and many were diagnosed as ill with malaria, a disease common in West Africa, transmitted by mosquitoes and not contagious from one person to another.

Exit screening at airports in countries affected by Ebola remains the principle means of keeping travelers from spreading Ebola to other nations. All three of these nations have asked for, and continue to receive, CDC assistance in strengthening exit screening
 

Attachments

Re: CDC Chief: Oops...do over..enhanced airport screening announced October 8 - Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Airport Ebola screens hampered by dormant virus, Tylenol

By Mark Drajem and Alan Levin, Bloomberg News, Bloomberg
October 9, 2014, 10:20 AM

WASHINGTON ?...

While enhanced screening announced Wednesday for New York's John F. Kennedy and four other U.S. airports will help stem the disease's spread, it's an imperfect defense against a complex public health emergency, said Lawrence Gostin, a professor of global health law at Georgetown University in Washington.

The reliability of screening arriving passengers rests largely on travelers being honest about whether they have come in contact with others infected with Ebola. And tricks such as taking Tylenol before landing to help ensure they can pass a fever test when going through Customs have been used by passengers before, such as during the 2003 SARS virus outbreak.

"If the goal is 100 percent effectiveness in terms of keeping Ebola patients out of the country, this won't work," Anish Jha, a professor at the Harvard School of Public Health in Boston, said in an interview. The increased screening "is a step in the right direction but it's hardly foolproof."
...
The U.S. still must address visitors from West Africa, including more than 40,000 in the past six months alone, according to Thomas Frieden, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

More...
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/sns-wp-blm-news-bc-ebola-airports09-20141009-story.html
 
Re: CDC Chief: Oops...do over..enhanced airport screening announced October 8 - Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

Majority of Americans Want Flights Banned From Ebola Countries: Survey

By Phil Helsel

A majority of Americans support banning all flights to the United States from countries experiencing an Ebola outbreak, an exclusive NBC News online survey reveals.

The survey, which was conducted by SurveyMonkey and then weighted for age, race, sex, education and region to match U.S. Census data, found that 58 percent of Americans want a ban on incoming flights from West African countries hardest hit by the virus, such as Liberia, Guinea, and Sierra Leone. Twenty percent of respondents opposed a travel ban, and the rest said they didn?t know. The survey was conducted a day before the first person diagnosed with Ebola inside the U.S. died Wednesday.
...
http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/eb...flights-banned-ebola-countries-survey-n221751
 
Re: CDC Chief: Oops...do over..enhanced airport screening announced October 8 - Banning Flights from Ebola-Ridden African Nations Will Cause More Americans to Get Ebola

This is the first article I've read on this topic by someone who is an authority on international travel and national security.

The Case For Suspending Visas in Ebola Affected Countries

Michael Chertoff was secretary of homeland security from 2005 to 2009 and is co-founder and executive chairman of the Chertoff Group, a security and risk-management firm
....​

No doubt the experts who reject travel bans understand disease and epidemiology. But their arguments demonstrate less understanding of how we manage risk in the context of border and travel security. In fact, restriction of U.S. travel visas for residents of Liberia, Guinea and Sierra Leone — the three countries in which Ebola is out of control — could reduce the risk of significant disease import into the United States without hampering efforts to assist those nations in combating the illness.
 
Back
Top