• FluTrackers.com Inc. does not provide medical advice. Information on this web site is collected from various internet resources, and the FluTrackers board of directors makes no warranty to the safety, efficacy, correctness or completeness of the information posted on this site by any author or poster. The information collated here is for instructional and/or discussion purposes only and is NOT intended to diagnose or treat any disease, illness, or other medical condition. Every individual reader or poster should seek advice from their personal physician/healthcare practitioner before considering or using any interventions that are discussed on this website. By continuing to access this website you agree to consult your personal physican before using any interventions posted on this website, and you agree to hold harmless FluTrackers.com Inc., the board of directors, the members, and all authors and posters for any effects from use of any medication, supplement, vitamin or other substance, device, intervention, etc. mentioned in posts on this website, or other internet venues referenced in posts on this website.
  • We are not asking for any donations. Do not donate to any entity who says they are raising funds for us.

Russia’s Alleged Systematic Program for the Re-education and Adoption of Ukraine's Children

Mary Wilson

Well-known member
14 February 2023

Introduction

Russia’s federal government has systematically relocated at least 6,000 children from Ukraine to a network of re-education and adoption facilities in Russia-occupied Crimea and mainland Russia. The Yale School of Public Health’s Humanitarian Research Lab (HRL) identified 43 facilities involved in holding children from Ukraine since Russia’s 24 February 2022 invasion of Ukraine. The majority are recreational camps where children are taken for ostensible vacations, while others are facilities used to house children put up for foster care or adoption in Russia. These findings indicate the majority of camps have engaged in pro-Russia re-education efforts and some camps have provided military training to children or suspended the children’s return to their parents in Ukraine.

Produced as part of the Conflict Observatory, this report documents the widespread nature of these facilities and their intended purposes. The report also explores the vast network of people responsible for facilitating the transfer of Ukrainian children to Russia. ...

https://hub.conflictobservatory.org/...ildren-camps-1
 
Last edited by a moderator:
14 FEBRUARY 2023
RUSSIA’S SYSTEMATIC PROGRAM FOR THE RE-EDUCATION & ADOPTION of UKRAINE’S CHILDREN
A CONFLICT OBSERVATORY REPORT

Humanitarian Research Lab at Yale School of Public Health

CONTENTS

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Introduction
Key Findings
Background on system of children’s camps
Methodology
Legal analysis and recommendations

LOGISTICS AND CONCERNING TRENDS WITHIN CAMP SYSTEM 9 2.a.
How and why children are transported to Russia and Russia-occupied territory
Supposed recreation camps

Russia’s designation of orphans
Experiences of children in the camps
Suspended return
Communication limitations and restrictions
Consent crisis
Re-education
Academic instruction
Military training
How children leave camps
Ukrainian government and civil society intervention
Parental retrieval of children

POLITICALCOORDINATIONOFCAMPSYSTEM&ADOPTIONS
Senior federal leadership
Patronage system, regional & local offcial involvement
Russia-aligned occupation authorities involvement in camps and facilities
Occupation authorities

LEGAL ANALYSIS

https://hub.conflictobservatory.org...t/items/97f919ccfe524d31a241b53ca44076b8/data
 
It's sad that the West took little interest in the plight of Ukrainian 'orphans' prior to Russia's intervention. I was shocked to see how difficult life has been for them there, in spite of the many billions US taxpayers have poured into the country over the past 10 or so years. It's possible some will be better cared for if they are adopted in Russia. NYT did a story about a social orphan who had been living in a TB hospital in Ukraine and was adopted in Russia. She said she was well-treated, but missed her friends. NYT located her mother so they could talk. She was reported to be living on a small disability in Kiev.

https://web.archive.org/web/2020111...s/news/ukraine-orphans-a-disturbing-situation
Ukraine: Orphans, A Disturbing Situation
February 03, 2020
Orphans in Ukraine: A Quick Glance


Right now, there are about 70,000-110,000 orphans in Ukraine (depending on which statistics you use). These orphans are housed in over 650 institutions across the country. The majority of these children are “social orphans”, meaning they were put in the care of the state due to abuse, abandonment or extreme poverty. Every three days an orphan with a disability dies, usually because they don’t get the necessary medical attention. In Ukraine, the orphanage, known as an Internat, is a mixed boarding school for orphans and children from families living in poverty and is a catch-all for children of every background and need.
Why are there so many orphans in Ukraine?

Ukraine, a country in Eastern Europe, achieved independence from the Soviet Union in 1991. This independence brought joy as well as instability and economic turmoil. The economy is growing, but millions of people still live in poverty across Ukraine today. Often, children experience the worst effects of this instability and economic turmoil.
  • Unemployment – Many factories and industries from Soviet times have closed, leaving people without any means of earning an income.
  • Poverty – With no work or government welfare to fall back on, people struggle to find money to buy food, clothing and medicine. Many lose their homes.
  • Collapse of Social Programs – The old Soviet day-care programs are gone and there are no established private industries to care for children.
  • Alcoholism – Many children in Ukraine become orphans, abandoned in the hospital by their alcoholic parents or are taken away by the state to adequately provide for the child.
  • Illness & poor medical care – Resulting in early death of their parents, many children in Ukraine become orphans due to lack of access to healthcare
  • Other social problems – Abuse and neglect leads to children living in Ukrainian orphanages, where some are taken by Social Services to provide them with a safe environment.
  • Crime – Given the desperate state of the economy, many people turn to crime to survive. Many are caught and end up in prison, leaving their children with either a single parent who struggles to provide for their family or no parent at all.
  • War in the East - Since 2014, Ukraine has been in conflict with Russia. Thousands have been killed in this conflict, leaving orphans and widows behind
Ukrainian Orphans Face a Grim Future


Living conditions at Ukrainian orphanages are very difficult for the children who end up there. Since they come from backgrounds that are usually complex and lacking in love and parental care, their situation often goes from bad to worse.

For example, Olga, one of numerous Ukrainian orphans, shares a large room with eight other orphans and uses the communal girl’s bathroom down the hall, where she may have a shower once a week. (During the day hours, the children use outhouses.) In Ukraine, orphans are given bunks to sleep on and donated clothing to wear. Orphanages also provide schooling, but the lessons are often outdated, leaving orphans far behind the education of other children. Meals are high in carbohydrates and low in protein with virtually no fresh fruits or vegetables served. After school, the caregivers keep the children occupied with chores, homework tasks and busywork.

Around the age of 16, orphans in Ukraine must leave the orphanage. There is no funding for them to remain, and most leave without the basic skills to protect or provide for themselves. These orphan graduates face a grim future, as they are left to fend for themselves in a world that is not welcoming to them and for which they are vastly unprepared.

Because many orphans have nowhere else to turn, 60-70% of Ukrainian orphans become involved in prostitution and organized crime. Twenty percent of children graduating from internats at age 16 end up in prison. Ten percent go on to commit or attempt suicide. Others embrace alcoholism and produce a new generation for the orphanage. Less than one percent make it to a university or higher education...
 
https://web.archive.org/web/2020103...owusa.org/blogs/news/covid-summer-for-orphans
COVID Summer for Orphans
September 07, 2020

Imagine being a child living in an orphanage. For most, it is a safe place of refuge – complete with nutritious food, reasonable education, adequate housing and free from the abuse and neglect that usually placed the child there in the first place. That is totally true for the 187 children we help care for at Shpola Orphanage in Ukraine.
Enter COVID-19 into the picture and everything changes…


In a nutshell, in an effort to control the spread of the Coronavirus, this past spring the government of Ukraine issued a nationwide quarantine, closed the border, all schools and orphanages and sent the children “home”. Every child in an institution has a guardian of sorts – this could be a birth parent with limited rights to the child, a relative who has been appointed as legal guardian, or a government official (like the Director of an orphanage) in the case where no other guardian can be found. All of these people, for one reason or another, have chosen not to raise the child and have instead sent them to the orphanage to live. Normally, these guardians are asked to take the children home on the occasional weekend, some holidays and 2 months during the summer. Most guardians, if they are relatives, are usually very poor and live in abject poverty so having children to feed at home is a difficult burden.

However, the children were still sent “home” for almost 6 months!

Instead of online distance learning, writing happy messages with chalk on sidewalks and sourcing the cutest mask, orphans were thrown back into the very environment they escaped from. So, what did they do? How did they cope?

Yarik, a 4[SUP]th[/SUP] grader, became a farmer. He managed to buy some seeds and then coaxed out some food from a long-neglected vegetable garden. He later became an enterprising milkman, going door to door selling small jars of milk to provide for his 6 siblings since his mentally disabled mother was “elsewhere". Vika (14) and Maxim (15), whose parents were nowhere to be found, pooled their strength to look after their 4 younger siblings; doing laundry by hand, trying to find clothes for the baby – even if this meant putting a winter coat on her. By tending the neighbor’s goats, they traded wages for milk, but no one had diapers, so they did without. Anya, a 6[SUP]th[/SUP] grade girl, became primary caregiver to her alcoholic mother, grandfather and 2 brothers – she was far too busy cooking stone soup every day to keep up with her homework. Yulia (10) and Alexandra (6) were living in a dilapidated house covered in trash, broken vodka bottles and very drunk relatives of various ages and states of inebriation. The girls spent most of their quarantine terrified and hiding in the bushes – finally seeking shelter at the village mayor’s home...
 
Emily. The above articles you have posted here are from a blog by Hope Now Ministries, [US based charity - address removed], dated 2020.
The articles have nothing to do with the Russian/Ukraine war and war crimes that began on February 24 2022.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Russia deports thousands of Ukrainian children. Investigators say that's a war crime

February 14, 20231:01 PM ET
DEBORAH AMOS

https://www.npr.org/2023/02/14/1156...hildren-deportation-possible-war-crime-report
________________________________________________________________
Ukraine: Recent Reporting on Child Relocations

Evidence of Russia’s War Crimes and Other Atrocities in Ukraine: Recent Reporting on Child Relocations

FPC BRIEFING

NATHANIEL A. RAYMOND, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF YALE'S HUMANITARIAN RESEARCH LAB AND LECTURER IN DEPARTMENT OF THE EPIDEMIOLOGY OF MICROBIAL DISEASES (EMD) AT YALE SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH.

CAITLIN HOWARTH, DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS FOR THE CONFLICT OBSERVATORY TEAM BASED AT YALE HUMANITARIAN RESEARCH LAB.

TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 14, 2023, 1:00 P.M. ET

WASHINGTON D.C.

FEBRUARY 14, 2023

SUMMARY
  • In this on-the-record, virtual briefing, research experts from the Yale Humanitarian Lab (Yale HRL) discuss findings in a report through the U.S. State Department-supported Conflict Observatory program that details Russia’s system to forcibly relocate and “re-educate” Ukraine’s children, including in locations deep in Russia thousands of miles from their homes. ...
​​​​​​​https://www.state.gov/briefings-for...ukraine-recent-reporting-on-child-relocations
 
I think it is relevant to distinguish factual information about the treatment of orphans in Ukraine from one-sided war propaganda.
 
If Russians are really re-educating Ukrainian orphans, I hope they don't replace hate with more hate. It only rots people from inside out.

Teaching hate in a Ukrainian school: https://t.me/voenkor_evtushenko/3656

https://www.newsweek.com/ukrainian-...ediatric-director-comments-war-russia-1782144
'I Want Them to Hate Russians': Ukrainian Mother on Struggles of War
By Nick Mordowanec On 2/18/23 at 6:00 AM EST
"I want them to hate Russians."

That is what Dr. Zoranya Ivanyuk, deputy director of Saint Nicholas Pediatric Hospital in Lviv, Ukraine, teaches her daughter, 12, and son, 6, following Russia's invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022.
...
"It is not only the fault of Putin," she said. "Every Russian absolutely is responsible for everything that is going on here. Every Russian. And what I want my children in their future to know is, I want them to hate Russians and remember everything that was done by them here. And I want Russians to be afraid of Ukrainians. I will be happy with that."
 
They will have to be really careful these children don't end up mistreated when they bring them back. Unwisely, the Russian state had a few of the children participate in a patriotic rally recently. The oldest Ukrainian girl, only 13, started getting insulted and threatened with hanging on social media by Ukrainians who recognized her.

https://euroweeklynews.com/2023/03/2...safe-to-do-so/
Russian diplomat Vasily Nebenzya insists Ukrainian children will be returned once it is safe to do so
By Chris King • 21 March 2023 • 1:40
 
Last edited:
Back
Top