Announcement

**Pathfinder** · February 20, 2018, 11:22 AM

Preliminary Communication

February 15, 2018
Neurological Manifestations Among US Government Personnel Reporting Directional Audible and Sensory Phenomena in Havana, Cuba

Randel L. Swanson II, DO, PhD^1,2; Stephen Hampton, MD^1,2; Judith Green-McKenzie, MD, MPH^2,3; et alRamon Diaz-Arrastia, MD, PhD^2,4; M. Sean Grady, MD^2,5; Ragini Verma, PhD^2,6; Rosette Biester, PhD^1,2; Diana Duda, PT, DPT^2,7; Ronald L. Wolf, MD, PhD^2,6; Douglas H. Smith, MD^2,5
Author Affiliations Article Information
JAMA. Published online February 15, 2018. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.1742

editorial comment icon

Editorial Comment

Related Articles

multimedia icon

Multimedia

Audio(29:14) Medical Findings In U.S. Government Personnel Reporting Symptoms After Exposure To Sensory Phenomena in Havana, Cuba

Key Points

Question Are there neurological manifestations associated with reports of audible and sensory phenomena among US government personnel in Havana, Cuba?
Findings In this case series of 21 individuals exposed to directional audible and sensory phenomena, a constellation of acute and persistent signs and symptoms were identified, in the absence of an associated history of blunt head trauma. Following exposure, patients experienced cognitive, vestibular, and oculomotor dysfunction, along with auditory symptoms, sleep abnormalities, and headache.
Meaning The unique circumstances of these patients and the consistency of the clinical manifestations raised concern for a novel mechanism of a possible acquired brain injury from a directional exposure of undetermined etiology.
Abstract

Importance From late 2016 through August 2017, US government personnel serving on diplomatic assignment in Havana, Cuba, reported neurological symptoms associated with exposure to auditory and sensory phenomena.
Objective To describe the neurological manifestations that followed exposure to an unknown energy source associated with auditory and sensory phenomena.
Design, Setting, and Participants Preliminary results from a retrospective case series of US government personnel in Havana, Cuba. Following reported exposure to auditory and sensory phenomena in their homes or hotel rooms, the individuals reported a similar constellation of neurological symptoms resembling brain injury. These individuals were referred to an academic brain injury center for multidisciplinary evaluation and treatment.
Exposures Report of experiencing audible and sensory phenomena emanating from a distinct direction (directional phenomena) associated with an undetermined source, while serving on US government assignments in Havana, Cuba, since 2016.
Main Outcomes and Measures Descriptions of the exposures and symptoms were obtained from medical record review of multidisciplinary clinical interviews and examinations. Additional objective assessments included clinical tests of vestibular (dynamic and static balance, vestibulo-ocular reflex testing, caloric testing), oculomotor (measurement of convergence, saccadic, and smooth pursuit eye movements), cognitive (comprehensive neuropsychological battery), and audiometric (pure tone and speech audiometry) functioning. Neuroimaging was also obtained.
Results Of 24 individuals with suspected exposure identified by the US Department of State, 21 completed multidisciplinary evaluation an average of 203 days after exposure. Persistent symptoms (>3 months after exposure) were reported by these individuals including cognitive (n = 17, 81%), balance (n = 15, 71%), visual (n = 18, 86%), and auditory (n = 15, 68%) dysfunction, sleep impairment (n = 18, 86%), and headaches (n = 16, 76%). Objective findings included cognitive (n = 16, 76%), vestibular (n = 17, 81%), and oculomotor (n = 15, 71%) abnormalities. Moderate to severe sensorineural hearing loss was identified in 3 individuals. Pharmacologic intervention was required for persistent sleep dysfunction (n = 15, 71%) and headache (n = 12, 57%). Fourteen individuals (67%) were held from work at the time of multidisciplinary evaluation. Of those, 7 began graduated return to work with restrictions in place, home exercise programs, and higher-level work-focused cognitive rehabilitation.
Conclusions and Relevance In this preliminary report of a retrospective case series, persistent cognitive, vestibular, and oculomotor dysfunction, as well as sleep impairment and headaches, were observed among US government personnel in Havana, Cuba, associated with reports of directional audible and/or sensory phenomena of unclear origin. These individuals appeared to have sustained injury to widespread brain networks without an associated history of head trauma.

Introduction

In late 2016, US government personnel serving in Havana, Cuba, began presenting to their embassy medical unit after experiencing unusual auditory and/or sensory stimuli of variable intensity and character, with associated onset of varied neurological manifestations. Initial signs and symptoms pointed toward injury of the auditory system, leading to the establishment of a triage program at the University of Miami centered around otolaryngology evaluation. Eighty embassy community members underwent initial evaluation between February and April 2017, and 16 individuals were identified with similar exposure history and a constellation of neurological signs and symptoms commonly seen following mild traumatic brain injury, also referred to as concussion.¹ Exposures continued with time and 8 additional individuals were identified who had similar findings. The US Department of State, Bureau of Medical Services, subsequently convened an expert panel in July 2017, which came to consensus that the triage findings were most likely related to neurotrauma from a nonnatural source and recommended that further investigation into this novel cluster of findings was necessary.
The University of Pennsylvania?s Center for Brain Injury and Repair was subsequently selected to coordinate multidisciplinary clinical evaluation, treatment, and rehabilitation of individuals identified during initial triage and additional patients with exposure. The purpose of this preliminary communication is to describe preliminary findings from 21 patients who were exposed to the same nonnatural source.¹
Methods

Design

This retrospective study was approved by the institutional review board of the University of Pennsylvania?s Perelman School of Medicine, which waived the need for informed consent. The participants signed general consent forms for treatment permitting use of their data in research. Because of security and confidentiality considerations, individual-level demographic data cannot be reported.
Clinical Approach

The US Department of State directly referred individuals with suspected exposure to the University of Pennsylvania for comprehensive evaluation and treatment. A multidisciplinary team was convened consisting of physical medicine and rehabilitation, occupational medicine, neurology, neuroradiology, and neurosurgery. Each specialist independently obtained clinical histories and conducted comprehensive assessments. Reported signs and symptoms were extracted from these interviews.
Based on individual clinical indication, additional referrals were made to vestibular physical therapy, neuro-optometry, neuropsychology, occupational therapy, speech therapy, audiology, otorhinolaryngology, and sleep medicine for focused evaluation and treatment. Patients were referred to the University of Pennsylvania for clinical care, as opposed to enrollment in a structured research study. The Box shows an abbreviated list of objective measures used during clinical assessments and supplements for additional information.²^{- 29}
Box.
Examples of Standardized Measures Used in Clinical Assessments^a

Cognitive
- Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination²
- California Verbal Learning Test?2nd Edition³
- Grooved Pegboard⁴
- Test of Memory Malingering⁵
- Trail Making Test, Parts A and B⁶
- Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale?IV⁷
- Wechsler Memory Scale?IV⁸
Mood
- Beck Depression Inventory (2nd edition)⁹
- Beck Anxiety Inventory¹⁰^,11
- Frontal Systems Behavior Scale¹²
- Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Checklist¹³^,14
Balance and vestibular
- Functional Gait Assessment¹⁵
- Activities-Specific Balance Confidence¹⁶
- Balance Error Scoring System¹⁷
- Clinical Test of Sensory Organization and Balance¹⁸^,19
- Dizziness Handicap Index²⁰
- Computerized Dynamic Posturography²¹^,22
- Caloric reflex test²³^,24
Vision and oculomotor
- Formal Evaluation of Vergence and Accommodation²⁵^,26
- Convergence Insufficiency Symptoms Survey²⁷
- Developmental Eye Movement Test²⁶^,28
- Vestibular/Ocular Motor Screening²⁹

^a Measures were used based on clinical indications; therefore, every patient did not complete all measures in this abbreviated list.

Cognitive, Neurobehavioral, and Mood Evaluations

When clinically indicated, comprehensive neuropsychological assessments were conducted by experienced neuropsychologists, who were not blinded to patient status. Neuropsychological test batteries included assessment of the following domains: (1) auditory attention, (2) auditory and visual working memory, (3) auditory and visual memory, (4) visual-spatial perception, (5) visual-motor construction, (6) motor function, (7) language function, (8) executive function, (9) processing speed, (10) academic achievement, (11) reasoning, (12) mood functioning, and (13) effort (Box and eAppendix in the Supplement). Following neuropsychological testing, individuals with cognitive deficits were referred for cognitive rehabilitation with occupational therapy, speech therapy, or both, depending on the individual clinical indication. Cognitive rehabilitation was intentionally not started prior to completion of neuropsychological testing to avoid affecting results.
Balance and Vestibular Evaluations

Clinical evaluations identifying balance abnormalities prompted referral to vestibular physical therapy. Focused vestibular evaluation included expert clinical assessment and the use of validated measures of static and dynamic balance (Box).¹⁵^{- 21} Also per clinical indications, patients were referred to audiology for comprehensive evaluation of the peripheral vestibular system, including caloric reflex testing.²³^,24 Individuals confirmed to have a unilateral peripheral vestibulopathy (ie, relative vestibular reduction of ≥25% on caloric reflex testing) underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the head with and without gadolinium contrast, with focus on the internal auditory canals in addition to the MRI sequences detailed.
Oculomotor Evaluations

Individuals found on clinical evaluation to have abnormalities of oculomotor function were referred to neuro-optometry for further evaluation and treatment. Oculomotor function was quantified using the following standard optometric clinical measures (Box).²⁵^,26 Vergence testing included step vergence with prism bar, vergence facility with prisms, and near point of convergence. Accommodative testing in nonpresbyopic patients included amplitude of accommodation, accommodative facility with plus and minus lenses, and accommodative lag. Pursuit and saccadic testing was done qualitatively to assess accuracy of tracking eye movements and whether symptoms were provoked as with Vestibular/Ocular Motor Screening.²⁹ Saccadic speed and accuracy were quantified using the Developmental Eye Movement test,²⁶^,28 a timed visual-verbal test. Diagnoses of accommodative, vergence, and/or saccadic/pursuit dysfunction were made using standardized criteria, in conjunction with symptomatic reporting,²⁶ which were quantified using the Convergence Insufficiency Symptoms Survey.²⁷
Auditory Evaluations

Audiometry evaluations were performed prior to referral for care at the University of Pennsylvania. However, when patients had balance function testing as described here, comprehensive audiology evaluation included both pure tone and speech audiometry.
Imaging Evaluations

Initial conventional MRI sequences were acquired at 3T on a Siemens Magnetom Prisma^fit scanner, and included high-resolution sagittal 3-dimensional MP-RAGE, T2 SPACE and FLAIR SPACE, coronal 2-dimensional T2-weighted imaging, axial 2-dimensional diffusion-weighted imaging, and axial T2* gradient echo. Resulting images were clinically interpreted by neuroradiology clinicians.
Results

There were 21 individuals evaluated (11 women and 10 men, with a mean age of 43 years). Multidisciplinary evaluations began an average of 203 days (range, 3-331 days; median, 189 days; interquartile range, 125 days) following exposure (Table 1).
Exposure

For 18 of the 21 individuals (86%), there were reports of hearing a novel, localized sound at the onset of symptoms in their homes and hotel rooms (Table 2). Affected individuals described the sounds as directional, intensely loud, and with pure and sustained tonality. Of the patients, high-pitched sound was reported by 16 (76%), although 2 (10%) noted a low-pitched sound. Words used to describe the sound include ?buzzing,? ?grinding metal,? ?piercing squeals,? and ?humming.?
The sounds were often associated with pressurelike (n = 9, 43%) or vibratory (n = 3, 14%) sensory stimuli, which were also experienced by 2 of the 3 patients who did not hear a sound. The sensory stimuli were likened to air ?baffling? inside a moving car with the windows partially rolled down.
Both the sound and sensory stimuli were often described as directional in that the individuals perceived a distinct direction from which the sensation emanated (hereafter referred to as directional phenomena). Further, the directional phenomena appeared to be localized to a precise area, as individuals (n = 12, 57%) noted that after changing location, the sensation disappeared and the associated symptoms reduced. Five individuals (24%) reported covering their head and/or ears, although doing so did not result in attenuation of the directional phenomena.
Accurately determining the dose and duration of exposure has been difficult because of the limitations of patient recall. Some patients were awakened by sounds and were unsure of the start of the event. The shortest reported event involved two 10-second pulses reported as a single exposure episode, whereas other patients reported that they perceived sound continuously for longer than 30 minutes. Owing to security concerns, further details of potential dosage cannot be provided.
Of the affected individuals, 20 (95%) reported immediate onset of neurological symptoms associated with directional phenomena (eTable 1 in the Supplement). One individual awoke from sleep with acute symptoms (including headache, unilateral ear pain, and hearing changes) but did not perceive directional phenomena. From days to weeks after exposure, individuals reported that they experienced the onset of additional cognitive, neurobehavioral/mood, and physical symptoms. Twenty individuals (95%) reported that they experienced persistent (>3 months) symptoms, and 18 individuals (86%) exhibited objective clinical manifestations in 6 predominant domains (Table 3).
Cognitive, Neurobehavioral, and Mood Findings

Persistent cognitive manifestations were reported by 17 individuals (81%). Subjective symptoms included memory problems (n = 16, 76%), feeling mentally foggy (n = 16, 76%), impaired concentration (n = 15, 71%), and feeling cognitively slowed (n = 14, 67%) (Table 3). In addition, they reported neurobehavioral difficulties including irritability (n = 14, 67%), nervousness (n = 12, 57%), feeling more emotional (n = 11, 52%), and sadness (n = 5, 24%). For at least 6 individuals (29%), a clear change in work performance was noted by supervisors and colleagues (eTable 1 in the Supplement). Individuals also reported a ?good day?bad day? pattern where significant cognitive or physical exertion would be followed by exacerbation of their symptoms for several days. Cognitive symptoms, as well as disequilibrium and headache, reportedly were also frequently exacerbated by cardiovascular exercise.
Multidisciplinary evaluations raised concern for cognitive impairment in 16 individuals (76%). Prior to referral, 4 of these individuals underwent neuropsychological evaluation (data not shown as generated outside of the University of Pennsylvania). Repetition of comprehensive neuropsychological testing is precluded within 1 year due of practice effects when material is presented within this timeframe. With previous exposure to material, the individual may score higher on a repeated neuropsychological evaluation within 1 year. Neuropsychological assessments were performed on 10 individuals after referral. Of those, interpretation was ongoing in 4 at the time of this publication. Per their preference, 2 individuals did not complete neuropsychological testing.
For the 6 individuals with complete neuropsychological testing data and analysis at the University of Pennsylvania, all had significant areas of cognitive weakness and/or impairment (eTables 2, 3, and 4 in the Supplement). Impairments were found in executive function (n = 6), motor function (n = 5), auditory and visual memory (n = 4), visual-spatial perception and visual-motor construction (n = 4), auditory attention and working memory (n = 3), language (n = 3), processing speed (n = 4), and reasoning (n = 1). All individuals demonstrated a high level of effort during testing and had intact cognitive domains including visual working memory and academic achievement.
Neurobehavioral function was evaluated using the Frontal System Behavior Scale, a self-report measure of frontal lobe dysfunction. Specifically, comparing before and after exposure retrospectively via patient recall and self-report, individuals noted apathy (n = 5), executive dysfunction (n = 4), and disinhibition (n = 2). Two individuals met criteria for posttraumatic stress disorder and endorsed severe levels of anger on the Brief Mood Survey, 1 of whom also endorsed moderate to severe levels of depression and anxiety.
Balance and Vestibular Findings

Individuals described acute nausea (n = 7, 33%) and dizziness (n = 5, 24%) during exposure, which continued to progress in the subacute and persistent stages (acute stage = during or hours following exposure; subacute stage = days to weeks after exposure patient recall]; and persistent stage = more than 3 months after exposure). Specifically, more than 3 months after exposure, individuals reported a higher prevalence of dizziness (n = 13, 62%) and nausea (n = 7, 33%), in addition to general balance problems (n = 14, 67%) (Table 3). These symptoms were exacerbated by walking quickly, tasks involving head movements, complex visual environments, or in some cases while simply standing still. Balance symptoms were also worsened with eyes closed or in low light conditions.
Clinical examinations raised concern for balance impairment in 17 patients (81%), prompting referral to vestibular physical therapy. Focused vestibular evaluations demonstrated impairments in static postural stability (n = 16, 76%), dynamic balance (n = 16, 76%), and the vestibulo-ocular reflex (n = 15, 71%) (eTables 5, 6, and 7 in the Supplement). Patients with the most severe balance impairments on clinical evaluation underwent caloric reflex testing, which demonstrated peripheral vestibular dysfunction in 4 of 13 patients evaluated. MRI findings focusing on the internal auditory canals on these 4 patients were normal. Taken together, these balance symptoms and evaluation findings are consistent with central and, in some cases, peripheral vestibular abnormalities.
Oculomotor Findings

Of the individuals with persistent symptoms, 16 (76%) reported visual problems (Table 3). Light sensitivity (n = 13, 62%) and difficulty reading (n = 12, 57%) were also frequently reported. Eye strain (n = 11, 52%) was experienced particularly with reading and was associated with headaches, disequilibrium, and nausea.
Clinical examinations raised concern for oculomotor dysfunction in 15 individuals (71%), prompting referral to neuro-optometry. The most common findings confirmed on focused oculomotor evaluation were convergence insufficiency (n = 11, 52%), abnormal smooth pursuits (n = 11, 52%), and saccadic dysfunction (n = 10, 47%) (eTables 8 and 9 in the Supplement). Similar to vestibular testing that provoked symptoms, oculomotor examination elicited headache and disequilibrium.
Auditory Findings

At the onset of the directional phenomena, affected individuals reported hearing a loud sound (n = 18, 86%), associated with ear pain (n = 7,33%) and tinnitus (n = 6, 29%). Within days to weeks following exposure, individuals continued to report tinnitus (n = 12, 57%) and ear pain (n = 5, 24%), with the addition of a change in hearing (n = 7, 33%) and sensitivity to noise (n = 5, 24%). More than 3 months after exposure, sound sensitivity was the most common auditory concern (n = 14, 67%), followed by tinnitus (n = 12, 57%) and ear pressure (n = 8, 38%).
While 9 individuals (43%) reported persistent hearing reduction, pure tone audiometry, including pure tone average and word identification, revealed moderate to severe sensorineural hearing loss in 3 individuals (23%) (eTable 10 in the Supplement), who were fitted with hearing aids. For 2 individuals, the moderate to severe sensorineural hearing loss was unilateral and corresponded with the side of peripheral vestibular dysfunction on caloric testing. Otoscopy and tympanometry findings were unremarkable.
Sleep

Individuals commonly reported issues with sleep (n = 18, 86%), including reduced sleep duration (n = 15, 71%) and difficulty falling asleep (n = 14, 67%). In addition, individuals experienced significant daytime fatigue (n = 16, 76%). Most individuals required pharmacological intervention to improve subjective report of sleep architecture (n = 15, 71%) (eTable 11 in the Supplement).
Headaches

At the initiation of directional phenomena exposure, 8 individuals (38%) reported immediate onset of headache, while 5 (24%) reported intense head pressure. In the days to weeks following exposure, 17 individuals (81%) developed headaches, with 16 (76%) experiencing persistent headaches longer than 3 months after exposure (Table 3).
In the persistent stage, headaches were reported to be exacerbated or associated with cognitive tasks (n = 13, 62%), rehabilitative therapies (n = 11, 52%), photophobia (n = 9, 43%), and phonophobia (n = 6, 29%). Patients with antecedent headaches were able to differentiate the character of these headaches from that of their standard headaches. Headaches were generally reported to improve with medications (n = 12, 57%) and appropriate therapies for oculomotor and vestibular impairments (eTable 11 in the Supplement).
Imaging

MRI neuroimaging was obtained in all 21 patients. Most patients had conventional imaging findings, which were within normal limits, at most showing a few small nonspecific T2-bright foci in the white matter (n =9, 43%). There were 3 patients with multiple T2-bright white matter foci, which were more than expected for age, 2 mild in degree, and 1 with moderate changes. The pattern of conventional imaging findings in these cases was nonspecific with regard to the exposure/insult experienced, and the findings could perhaps be attributed to other preexisting disease processes or risk factors. Advanced structural and functional neuroimaging studies are ongoing.
Rehabilitation and Return to Work

Individualized rehabilitation programs were developed, which included combinations of neuro-optometric rehabilitation (n = 14, 67%), vestibular physical therapy (n = 17, 81%), and cognitive rehabilitation with speech pathology and/or occupational therapy (n = 13, 62%). The most symptomatic patients (n = 14, 67%) requiring multiple therapies did not return to work.
Vestibular physical therapy sessions focused on balance retraining, static and dynamic posture control with substitution via visual and somatosensory systems, gaze stabilization exercises, habituation, smooth pursuits, and saccadic eye movement exercises. Patients treated with vestibular rehabilitation have demonstrated a positive response with improved balance and reduction of disequilibrium.
Formal neuro-optometric rehabilitation, including manipulation of disparity vergence and accommodative amplitude and latency, has been used to treat ocular motor deficits. Rehabilitation for abnormal smooth pursuit and saccadic dysfunction was coordinated between neuro-optometric rehabilitation, vestibular physical therapy, and occupational therapy. Vestibular physical therapy focused on oculomotor function with the body in motion and occupational therapy emphasized functional tasks such as visual scanning in a simulated work environment.
Following comprehensive neuropsychological testing, a formal cognitive rehabilitation program was initiated in the form of occupational therapy and/or speech therapy.
Early return to work with intensive cognitive loading led to an exacerbation of neurocognitive, vestibular, and visual symptoms in 7 individuals (33%). Individualized return to work plans were designed to reintegrate individuals using a stepwise process and appropriate work modifications.
Discussion

Preliminary findings are described of a case series of individuals stationed in Havana, Cuba, nearly all of whom reported directional audible and/or sensory phenomena that was followed by the development of a consistent cluster of neurological signs and symptoms. The clinical manifestations may represent a novel clinical entity, which appears to have resulted from a widespread brain network dysfunction (ie, cognitive, oculomotor, and central vestibular) as seen in mild traumatic brain injury, or concussion,³⁰ as well as injury to the peripheral vestibular system in some cases. It is currently unclear if or how the noise is related to the reported symptoms. In particular, sound in the audible range (20 Hz-20 000 Hz) is not known to cause persistent injury to the central nervous system and therefore the described sounds may have been associated with another form of exposure.
Cognitive symptoms, including difficulty remembering (n=16, 76%) and feeling cognitively slowed (n=14, 67%) were the most problematic for individuals in this series more than 3 months after exposure, with neuropsychological testing identifying impairments in at least 1 cognitive domain in all 6 patients who completed neuropsychological evaluation to date (eTables 2, 3, and 4 in the Supplement). Cognitive difficulties interfered with these patients? ability to multitask, process information quickly with accurate recall, solve problems, and perform rapid decision making. Compared with vestibular and oculomotor impairments, cognitive impairments are often the slowest to improve following acquired brain injury, which was observed in this series. Therefore, extended cognitive rehabilitation with emphasis on return to work was used. In addition, it is not uncommon for patients with neurological injury resulting in cognitive impairment to have mood disturbances such as depression, anxiety, and/or posttraumatic stress disorder. Mood dysfunction can directly result from acquired brain injury or develop in response to the precipitating event and novel deficits.³¹^{- 33}
The presence of subjective neurological symptoms presenting in a cohesive community has raised concerns for collective delusional disorders, including mass psychogenic illness. However, neurological examination and cognitive screens did not reveal evidence of malingering, and objective testing and behavioral observations during cognitive testing indicated high levels of effort and motivation. Several of the objective manifestations consistently found in this cohort (such as oculomotor and vestibular testing abnormalities) could not have been consciously or unconsciously manipulated. Furthermore, mass psychogenic illness is often associated with transient, benign symptoms with rapid onset and recovery often beginning with older individuals.³⁴^,35 In contrast, the Havana cohort experienced persisting disability of a significant nature and are broadly distributed in age. Rather than seeking time away from the workplace, the patients were largely determined to continue to work or return to full duty, even when encouraged by health care professionals to take sick leave.
While not systematically excluded, viral etiologies, chemical etiologies, or both associated with acute onset of persistent neurological impairment and peripheral vestibulopathy with the directional nature of exposure descriptions are not readily apparent. No other manifestations of viral illness, such as preceding fever, were identified. It is unlikely a chemical agent could produce these neurological manifestations in the absence of other organ involvement, particularly given that some individuals developed symptoms within 24 hours of arriving in Havana.
There are important considerations in this investigation. In particular, the anatomic substrates causing the symptoms have not yet been identified. This may represent a significant challenge because even the designation of ?concussion,? is not yet a true diagnosis, as no definitions include the underlying cause. Nonetheless, there is an emerging consensus that concussion, or mild traumatic brain injury, is a type of brain network disorder, based on classic symptoms (eg, slowed processing speed and memory dysfunction) as well as changes in the white matter tracts and consecutive connectivity, as detected with advanced neuroimaging studies.³⁰^,36
Beyond the absence of blunt head trauma, there were additional notable differences between the manifestations observed in the Havana cohort and characteristic acute and persistent symptoms of concussion. For example, individuals experienced unilateral ear pain and tinnitus after exposure, and some were later detected to have a unilateral peripheral vestibulopathy (along with central vestibular dysfunction), a finding uncommon in concussion. Further, studies have reported that while most individuals following concussion have a relatively rapid full recovery, at least 15% are thought to experience characteristic persisting symptoms.³⁷^,38 In contrast to classic concussions, most patients referred following suspected exposure in Havana exhibited significant impairment that persisted for months with no significant improvement in multiple cases until rehabilitation was initiated.
For practicing clinicians, if a patient presents reporting a similar potential exposure and symptoms similar to those observed in mild traumatic brain injury, in addition to a thorough history, objective evaluation should include screening assessments of vestibular, oculomotor, and cognitive functioning. Based on findings of this assessment, appropriate referrals to subspecialists should be considered including neurorehabilitation physiatry, vestibular physical therapy, neuro-optometry, neuropsychology, and audiology.
Limitations

This study has several limitations. First, due to the sensitive nature of this publication, certain details typically reported in a case series of exposure were omitted, including specifics about geography, relationships between individuals, and individual demographics. Second, because these patients? first evaluation was elsewhere, each patient did not undergo each of the tests described. In particular, neuropsychological characterization was incomplete at the time of publication. Preliminary results were presented given the importance and strong public interest in this case series. Third, the rehabilitative course of this Havana cohort may not be representative because this represents a referral population. There may be additional individuals exposed while in Havana, Cuba, who have not been identified due to subtler manifestations that either resolved spontaneously or did not prompt presentation for medical treatment. Therefore, the actual number of individuals exposed is unknown, and the relative ?dose? of exposure that causes acute and chronic symptoms remains unclear.
Conclusions

In this preliminary report of a retrospective case series, persistent cognitive, vestibular, and oculomotor dysfunction, as well as sleep impairment and headaches, were observed among US government personnel in Havana, Cuba, associated with reports of directional audible and/or sensory phenomena of unclear origin. These individuals appeared to have sustained injury to widespread brain networks without an associated history of head trauma.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2673168

**Emily** · March 28, 2018, 02:53 AM

Finally, a Likely Explanation for the “Sonic Weapon” Used at the U.S. Embassy in Cuba

https://spectrum.ieee.org/semiconductors/devices/finally-a-likely-explanation-for-the-sonic-weapon-used-at-the-us-embassy-in-cuba

Researchers say bad engineering, not a deliberate attack, may be to blame

1 Mar 2018 | 13:00 GMT

Finally, a Likely Explanation for the ?Sonic Weapon? Used at the U.S. Embassy in Cuba

Researchers say bad engineering, not a deliberate attack, may be to blame

By Jean Kumagai

... Having reverse engineered the AP audio, Fu, Xu, and Yan then considered what combination of things might have caused the sound at the U.S. embassy in Cuba. ?If ultrasound is to blame, then a likely cause was two ultrasonic signals that accidentally interfered with each other, creating an audible side effect,? Fu says. There are existing sources of ultrasound in office environments, such as room-occupancy sensors [see, for example, ?How an Ultrasonic Sensor Nearly Derailed a Ph.D. Thesis?]. ?Maybe there was also an ultrasonic jammer in the room and an ultrasonic transmitter,? he suggests. ?Each device might have been placed there by a different party, completely unaware of the other.?
One thing the investigation didn?t explore was whether the AP audio could have produced the wide range of symptoms, including brain damage, that afflicted embassy workers. ?We know that audible signals can cause pain, but we didn?t look at the physiological effects beyond that,? Fu says...

I hope this won't spawn painful animal research. Our embassy staff should have been moved as soon as an environmental problem was noticed. Then engineers could have figured out what the problem was and fixed it.

**Pathfinder** · June 22, 2018, 09:05 AM

CBS/AP June 22, 2018, 6:07 AM

1 more U.S. worker in Cuba has "confirmed" mystery illness

WASHINGTON -- Medical tests have confirmed that one additional U.S. Embassy worker has been affected by mysterious health incidents in Cuba, the State Department said, bringing the total number to 25. The new "medically confirmed" worker is one of two who were recently evacuated from Cuba after reporting symptoms.

State Department spokeswoman Heather Nauert said the other worker is "still being evaluated" by doctors. Prior to the newest incident, the most recent medically confirmed case from Cuba had been in August 2017, Nauert said.

The confirmed Cuba patients have been found to have a range of symptoms and diagnoses including mild traumatic brain injury, also known as concussions.
...

1 more U.S. worker in Cuba has "confirmed" mystery illness

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-embassy-cuba-mystery-illness-new-medically-confirmed-case-state-department/

State Department says of 2 people most recently brought home, 1 case confirmed, other "still being evaluated"

**Emily** · June 22, 2018, 05:21 PM

The bad engineering possibility looks unlikely with a second outbreak in U.S, diplomats in another country:

A U.S. government employee in China recently reported subtle and vague, but abnormal, sensations of sound and pressure (U.S. Embassy in China, May 23, 2018) - FluTrackers News and Information

https://flutrackers.com/forum/forum/united-states/emerging-diseases-other-health-threats-ag/794528-a-u-s-government-employee-in-china-recently-reported-subtle-and-vague-but-abnormal-sensations-of-sound-and-pressure-u-s-embassy-in-china-may-23-2018

Health Alert Home (https://china.usembassy-china.org.cn/) | News & Events (https://china.usembassy-china.org.cn/news-events/) | Health Alert Location: Guangzhou Event:A U.S. government employee in China recently reported subtle and

There was a 3-yr-old child injured by the attacks in Cuba:

China says probe sheds no light on mystery illness striking U.S. diplomats

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-still-has-no-clue-about-mystery-illness-striking-us-diplomats-after-inquiry/2018/06/07/a328837a-6a2d-11e8-bbc5-dc9f3634fa0a_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.44cd344ba3d0

The United States has evacuated more U.S. from Guangzhou after they fell ill from hearing strange sounds.

Though no names were released, a Foreign Service officer, Mark Lenzi, told The Washington Post he would be evacuated along with his wife and 3-year-old son. Lenzi said he began hearing unusual sounds in April 2017, comparing them to rolling marbles with static. He said he started suffering excruciating headaches a few months later, as did his wife and son.

**Pathfinder** · December 14, 2018, 02:09 PM

Acute findings in an acquired neurosensory dysfunction

Michael E. Hoffer MD
Bonnie E. Levin PhD
Hillary Snapp AuD, PhD
James Buskirk PT, SCS
Carey Balaban PhD

First published: 12 December 2018

Just a moment...

https://doi.org/10.1002/lio2.231

Editor's Note: This Manuscript was accepted for publication 12 November 2018.

Conflict of Interest: : All authors have completed the ICMJE form for disclosure of potential conflict of interest. No conflicts were reported for this work.

Funding Support: : No funding was provided for this work.

Disclaimer: : The content and views expressed in this paper are those of the authors and do not represent the official views of the University of Miami, the University of Pittsburgh, the United States Department of State, the United States Department of Defense, or the United States Government.

SECTIONS
PDF
TOOLS
SHARE

Abstract

Background

In the Autumn of 2016, diplomatic personnel residing in Havana began to present with symptoms of dizziness, ear pain, and tinnitus that emerged after perception of high frequency noise and/or a pressure sensation. Understanding the acute symptoms of this disorder is important for better defining the disorder and developing optimal diagnostic, preventive, and treatment algorithms.

Objectives

To define the presenting symptoms in a cohort of patients in the acute time period after perceiving a noise/pressure exposure in Havana.

Design/Settings/Participants

Review of 25 symptomatic individuals who reported a localized sensation of noise/pressure and 10 asymptomatic individuals (roommates of those affected) who did not experience the sound/pressure.

Results

Immediately after the exposure, the majority of individuals reported intense ear pain in one or both ears and experienced tinnitus. All of the individuals noticed unsteadiness and features of cognitive impairment. On presentation to our center, dizziness (92%) and cognitive complaints (56%) were the most common symptoms. Formal testing revealed that 100% of individuals had an otolithic abnormality and evidence of cognitive dysfunction.

Conclusion and Relevance

This study focuses on the acute presentation of a phenomenon in which symptoms emerge after perception of a localized noise/pressure and in which the acute symptomology includes the universal nature of vestibular injuries and select cognitive deficits. The findings presented in this acute group of patients begin to provide a better picture of the initial injury pattern seen after this exposure and may allow for more accurate diagnosis of this disorder in future cases.
...

Just a moment...

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/lio2.231

Announcement

USA - The Department of State warns U.S. citizens not to travel to Cuba (September 29, 2017)

USA - The Department of State warns U.S. citizens not to travel to Cuba (September 29, 2017)

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment