Uttar Pradesh
CM: Lack of research made encephalitis major killer
TNN | Sep 17, 2017, 10:36 IST
LUCKNOW: Blaming lack of research for encephalitis becoming a major threat to lives of people in Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal and parts of Bihar, chief minister Aditya Nath Yogi asked director of SGPGIMS to send a research team to Gorakhpur to identify causes of the disease that manifests as brain fever.
The chief minister said, "Nobody paid due attention to the disease till 1977 and doctors kept dismissing it as an unknown killer disease. Had its causes been studied, we would have come a long way in its treatment." Yogi insisted SGPGIMS take up research in the eastern, central, western and Bundelk hand parts of the state to find out causes and treatment of the disease.
...
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/c...w/60717393.cms
Death of children in BRD is not new: CM Yogi
News18Hindi
Updated: September 16, 2017, 9:22 PM
Manmohan Ray,
Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath said at the death of innocent Muslims at Baba Raghav Das Medical College in Gorakhpur that this is not a new matter. CM said that he himself fought the battle of encephalitis from road to parliament. In the exclusive interview given to ETV / News18, Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath said, "Deaths are tragic. But it should not be politics. The media wrongly propagated this issue.
In our government, millions of children were vaccinated with encephalitis, but the media did not propagate this. "The
Chief Minister said that this is the first time that the number of deaths from encephalitis has decreased compared to the previous years. CM said that the deaths in BRD were linked to the lack of oxygen inadequate. The media wanted to make this issue sensational and she did the same.
...
https://hindi.news18.com/news/uttar-...n-1110298.html
Gorakhpur deaths: Police nab oxygen supplier in Deoria; all accused in FIR now arrested
More than 60 children, mostly infants, died within a week at the hospital last month. There were allegations that a disruption in oxygen supply - which occurred since the vendor hadn't been paid - had caused the deaths.
IndiaToday.in | Edited by Ganesh Kumar Radha Udayakumar
New Delhi, September 17, 2017 | UPDATED 10:57 IST
Manish Bhandari, the owner of a company (Pushpa Sales) that supplied oxygen to Gorakhpur's Baba Raghav Das (BRD) Medical College, has been arrested in Deoria, the news agency ANI reported.
...
http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/g...1/1049744.html
Comment: The CM may not be aware of recent research showing that encephalitis patients have been linked with high rates of positivity for Scrub Typhus. I'm also happy to fact check his claim of reduced encephalitis deaths this year. See the post immediately before this - While fewer cases have been seen at BRD this year, the case fatality rate is within the range seen in the previous 6 years. For Uttar Pradesh as a whole, figures from NVBDCP are below.
Year // AES cases // AES deaths // JE Cases // JE deaths / Mortality rate
2017 // 1,842 // 213 / 128 / 4 to August 31 / 11.6%
2016 // 1,431 / 224 / 81 / 6 to August 31 / 15.7%
2015 // 1,027 / 135 / 56 / 4 to August 31 / 13.1%
2014// 1,098 / 228 / 36 / 5 to August 27 / 20.8%
2013// 977 / 199 / 69 / 6 to August 31 / 20.3%
2012// 1,429 / 228 / NA / NA to August 31 / 16.0%
2011// 1,071 / 150 / NA / NA to August 23 / 14.0%
The number of cases this year is much higher than usual, but the numbers of fatalities has remained about the same. As a result the cfr has dropped. Why have the numbers increased so much this year? Perhaps due to the inclusion of scrub typhus patients in the case definition? Who knows. Historically, most patients are referred to BRD but, this year, it seems like half of the cases are not making it there. That's unusual. Has UP suddenly improved primary care and is curing more patients before they deteriorate significantly? That is possible given that there should be a new treatment regimen in place for scrub typhus. There's no way of knowing the answer to this because I'm not at all sure that anybody is monitoring to see if the scrub typhus treatments are even being performed.
Another very real possibility is that parents are bringing their children home to die, rather than to BRD because of the ongoing exposure of the dysfunction of that hospital after the oxygen crisis in August. Any deaths at home would not be compiled in the official statistics.
The per cent of patients testing positive for JE has not changed much this decade in spite of any vaccination campaigns. I suspect that many patients remain untested. - Ro
CM: Lack of research made encephalitis major killer
TNN | Sep 17, 2017, 10:36 IST
LUCKNOW: Blaming lack of research for encephalitis becoming a major threat to lives of people in Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal and parts of Bihar, chief minister Aditya Nath Yogi asked director of SGPGIMS to send a research team to Gorakhpur to identify causes of the disease that manifests as brain fever.
The chief minister said, "Nobody paid due attention to the disease till 1977 and doctors kept dismissing it as an unknown killer disease. Had its causes been studied, we would have come a long way in its treatment." Yogi insisted SGPGIMS take up research in the eastern, central, western and Bundelk hand parts of the state to find out causes and treatment of the disease.
...
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/c...w/60717393.cms
Death of children in BRD is not new: CM Yogi
News18Hindi
Updated: September 16, 2017, 9:22 PM
Manmohan Ray,
Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath said at the death of innocent Muslims at Baba Raghav Das Medical College in Gorakhpur that this is not a new matter. CM said that he himself fought the battle of encephalitis from road to parliament. In the exclusive interview given to ETV / News18, Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath said, "Deaths are tragic. But it should not be politics. The media wrongly propagated this issue.
In our government, millions of children were vaccinated with encephalitis, but the media did not propagate this. "The
Chief Minister said that this is the first time that the number of deaths from encephalitis has decreased compared to the previous years. CM said that the deaths in BRD were linked to the lack of oxygen inadequate. The media wanted to make this issue sensational and she did the same.
...
https://hindi.news18.com/news/uttar-...n-1110298.html
Gorakhpur deaths: Police nab oxygen supplier in Deoria; all accused in FIR now arrested
More than 60 children, mostly infants, died within a week at the hospital last month. There were allegations that a disruption in oxygen supply - which occurred since the vendor hadn't been paid - had caused the deaths.
IndiaToday.in | Edited by Ganesh Kumar Radha Udayakumar
New Delhi, September 17, 2017 | UPDATED 10:57 IST
Manish Bhandari, the owner of a company (Pushpa Sales) that supplied oxygen to Gorakhpur's Baba Raghav Das (BRD) Medical College, has been arrested in Deoria, the news agency ANI reported.
...
http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/g...1/1049744.html
Comment: The CM may not be aware of recent research showing that encephalitis patients have been linked with high rates of positivity for Scrub Typhus. I'm also happy to fact check his claim of reduced encephalitis deaths this year. See the post immediately before this - While fewer cases have been seen at BRD this year, the case fatality rate is within the range seen in the previous 6 years. For Uttar Pradesh as a whole, figures from NVBDCP are below.
Year // AES cases // AES deaths // JE Cases // JE deaths / Mortality rate
2017 // 1,842 // 213 / 128 / 4 to August 31 / 11.6%
2016 // 1,431 / 224 / 81 / 6 to August 31 / 15.7%
2015 // 1,027 / 135 / 56 / 4 to August 31 / 13.1%
2014// 1,098 / 228 / 36 / 5 to August 27 / 20.8%
2013// 977 / 199 / 69 / 6 to August 31 / 20.3%
2012// 1,429 / 228 / NA / NA to August 31 / 16.0%
2011// 1,071 / 150 / NA / NA to August 23 / 14.0%
The number of cases this year is much higher than usual, but the numbers of fatalities has remained about the same. As a result the cfr has dropped. Why have the numbers increased so much this year? Perhaps due to the inclusion of scrub typhus patients in the case definition? Who knows. Historically, most patients are referred to BRD but, this year, it seems like half of the cases are not making it there. That's unusual. Has UP suddenly improved primary care and is curing more patients before they deteriorate significantly? That is possible given that there should be a new treatment regimen in place for scrub typhus. There's no way of knowing the answer to this because I'm not at all sure that anybody is monitoring to see if the scrub typhus treatments are even being performed.
Another very real possibility is that parents are bringing their children home to die, rather than to BRD because of the ongoing exposure of the dysfunction of that hospital after the oxygen crisis in August. Any deaths at home would not be compiled in the official statistics.
The per cent of patients testing positive for JE has not changed much this decade in spite of any vaccination campaigns. I suspect that many patients remain untested. - Ro
Comment